1Silence! (feat. Deidre Goodwin, Brent Barrett, Callan Bergmann, Stephen Bienskie, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye, Lucia Spina)
2Thish Ish It / The Right Guide (feat. Deidre Goodwin, Callan Bergmann, Stephen Bienskie, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye, Lucia Spina, Jenn Harris)
3If I Could Smell Her Cunt (feat. Deidre Goodwin, Brent Barrett, Callan Bergmann, Stephen Bienskie, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye, Lucia Spina)
4Papa Shtarling (feat. Howard Kaye, Jenn Harris)
5It's Agent Shtarling (feat. Stephen Bienskie, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye, Jenn Harris)
6Are You About a Size 14? (feat. Callan Bergmann, Stephen Bienskie, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye, Lucia Spina)
7My Daughter Is Catherine (feat. Lucia Spina)
8Quid Pro Quo (feat. Brent Barrett, Jenn Harris, Silence! - The Musical Original Cast)
9I'd Fuck Me (feat. Callan Bergmann, Stephen Bienskie, Jeff Hiller, Lucia Spina)
10It's Me (feat. Brent Barrett, Callan Bergmann, Stephen Bienskie, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye)
11Catherine Dies Today (feat. Deidre Goodwin, Stephen Bienskie, Jenn Harris, Silence! - The Musical Original Cast)
12Papa Shtarling - Reprise (feat. Howard Kaye, Jenn Harris)
13Put the Fucking Lotion in the Basket (feat. Stephen Bienskie, Lucia Spina)
14We're Goin' In (feat. Callan Bergmann, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye)
15In the Dark with a Maniac / Bill's Death (feat. Stephen Bienskie, Lucia Spina, Jenn Harris, Silence! - The Musical Original Cast)
16Silence! Reprise & Finale (feat. Brent Barrett, Jenn Harris, Silence! - The Musical Original Cast)
