1Santa Barbara Skies (feat. James Roday, Dulé Hill)
2Z’s Lament (feat. Anthony Rapp)
3I’ve Heard It Both Ways (feat. James Roday, Timothy Omundson, Maggie Lawson)
4Sleigh Bells and Songs (feat. Ally Sheedy)
5(When You’re) Making Up a Song (feat. James Roday, Dulé Hill, Maggie Lawson, Ally Sheedy)
6Often It’s the Opposite (feat. Timothy Omundson, Maggie Lawson, Kurt Fuller)
7Into the Woods / I Hurt No One (feat. Anthony Rapp, James Roday)
8Act II Storybook Open (feat. Adam Cohen)
9I’ve Heard It Both Ways (reprise one) (feat. Timothy Omundson)
10Under Santa Barbara Skies (reprise) (feat. Timothy Omundson, Maggie Lawson, Kirsten Nelson)
11I’ve Heard It Both Ways (reprise two) (feat. James Roday, Timothy Omundson, Maggie Lawson)
12It’s Her (feat. Adam Cohen)
13Promised Land (feat. Ally Sheedy, Jimmi Simpson)
14Shawn Hears the Theme / The Breakdown (feat. Anthony Rapp, James Roday)
15Gus in the Spotlight (feat. Dulé Hill)
16The Surrender (feat. Anthony Rapp)
17Jamaican Inspector (feat. Dulé Hill)
