1Prologue: Once Upon a December (feat. Nicole Scimeca, Mary Beth Peil)
2A Rumor in St. Petersburg (feat. Christy Altomare, John Bolton, Derek Klena, Ramin Karimloo)
3In My Dreams (feat. Christy Altomare)
4Learn to Do It (feat. Christy Altomare, John Bolton, Derek Klena)
5The Neva Flows (feat. Ramin Karimloo)
6My Petersburg (feat. Derek Klena)
7Once Upon a December (feat. Massimo Altomare)
8Stay, I Pray You (feat. Christy Altomare, John Bolton, Derek Klena, Constantine Germanacos)
9We'll Go From There (feat. Christy Altomare, John Bolton, Derek Klena)
10Still (feat. Ramin Karimloo)
11Journey to the Past (feat. Christy Altomare)
12Paris Holds the Key (to Your Heart) (feat. Christy Altomare, John Bolton, Derek Klena)
13Crossing a Bridge (feat. Christy Altomare)
14Close the Door (feat. Mary Beth Peil)
15Land of Yesterday (feat. Caroline O’Connor)
16The Countess and the Common Man (feat. Caroline O’Connor, John Bolton)
17In a Crowd of Thousands (feat. Christy Altomare, Derek Klena)
18Meant to Be (feat. John Bolton)
19Quartet at the Ballet (feat. Christy Altomare, Mary Beth Peil, Derek Klena, Ramin Karimloo)
20Everything to Win (feat. Derek Klena)
21Once Upon a December (reprise) (feat. Christy Altomare, Mary Beth Peil)
22The Press Conference (feat. Caroline O’Connor, John Bolton)
23Everything to Win (reprise) (feat. Christy Altomare)
24Still / The Neva Flows (reprise) (feat. Christy Altomare, Ramin Karimloo)
25Finale (feat. Mary Beth Peil, Ramin Karimloo)
