1Overture (feat. Paul Williams, Paul Williams)
3Room in Your Heart (feat. Dr. Bunsen Honeydew, Beaker)
4Good King Wenceslas (feat. Muppet Brass Buskers)
5One More Sleep 'til Christmas (feat. Kermit the Frog)
6Marley and Marley (feat. Statler and Waldorf)
7Christmas Past (feat. Miles Goodman)
8Chairman of the Board (feat. Sam the Eagle)
9Fozziwig's Party (feat. The Electric Mayhem)
10When Love Is Gone (feat. Belle)
11It Feels Like Christmas (feat. Ghost of Christmas Present)
12Christmas Scat (feat. Kermit the Frog, Robin the Frog)
13Bless Us AllThe Muppets (feat. Robin the Frog)
14Christmas Future (feat. Miles Goodman)
15Christmas Morning (feat. Miles Goodman)
16Thankful Heart (feat. Ebenezer Scrooge)
17Finale: When Love Is Found / It Feels Like ChristmasThe Muppets (feat. Ghost of Christmas Present, Robin the Frog, Ebenezer Scrooge)
18When Love Is Gone (feat. Martina McBride)
19We Need a Little ChristmasThe Muppets
20Jingle Bell RockThe Muppets
21Deck the Halls / Jingle Bells / White Christmas / Winter Wonderland (medley) (feat. Sesame Street)
22I Hate Christmas (feat. Oscar the Grouch)
23We Wish You a Merry ChristmasThe Muppets, John Denver
24Have Yourselve A Merry Little ChristmasThe Muppets (feat. John Denver)
25Medley (feat. Sesame Street)
26Do You Hear What I Hear (feat. Elmo, Rosie O’Donnell)
27Twelve Days of ChristmasThe Muppets, John Denver
28Deck The HallsThe Muppets
29MedleyThe Muppets (feat. John Denver)
