1Main Title (The Second Star to the Right) / All This Has Happened Before (feat. The Jud Conlon Chorus, The Mellomen)
2The Last Night in the NurseryOliver Wallace
3On the Rooftop / What’s a Kiss? / Perturbed PixieOliver Wallace
4You Can Fly! You Can Fly! You Can Fly! (feat. The Jud Conlon Chorus, Bobby Driscoll, Kathryn Beaumont, Paul Collins, Tommy Luske)
5A Pirate’s Life (feat. The Mellomen)
6Blast That Peter Pan / A Pirate’s Life (reprise)Oliver Wallace
7The Legend of the Croc / Double the Powder and Shorten the Fuse / Follow Tinker BellOliver Wallace
8Just When I Brought You a Mother / BanishedOliver Wallace
9Following the Leader (feat. Bobby Driscoll, Paul Collins, Tommy Luske)
10Hide and Sneak / No Let ’em GoOliver Wallace
11Mermaid Lagoon / Bad Day at Skull RockOliver Wallace
12Plotting a Pixie’s PlightOliver Wallace
13What Made the Red Man Red? / Tinknapped (feat. The Mellomen, Candy Candido)
14Rumor Has It / Hangman’s TreeOliver Wallace
15Big Chief Flying Eagle / I Had a Mother OnceOliver Wallace
16Your Mother and Mine (feat. Kathryn Beaumont)
17Good‐Bye Peter / ShanghaiedOliver Wallace
18Captain Hook Never Breaks a Promise / The Elegant Captain Hook / A Little Surprise / Oh Tink / The Pen or the Plank (feat. Bill Thompson, The Mellomen, Hans Conried)
19No Splash / Take That / I’m a Codfish! / Crocbait / The Hero of NeverlandOliver Wallace
20Home Again / Mermaids, Pirates and Indians / Finale (You Can Fly! You Can Fly! You Can Fly!) (feat. The Jud Conlon Chorus)
21Never Smile at a CrocodileFrank Churchill
22The Boatswain’s Song (demo)Oliver Wallace
