1Opening (feat. Brian Stokes Mitchell, Robert Billig)
2Man of La Mancha (I, Don Quixote) (feat. Ernie Sabella, Brian Stokes Mitchell, Robert Billig)
3It’s All the Same (feat. Robert Billig, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio)
4Dulcinea (feat. Brian Stokes Mitchell, Robert Billig)
5I’m Only Thinking of Him (feat. Mark Jacoby, Robert Billig)
6We’re Only Thinking of Him (feat. Stephen Bogardus, Robert Billig)
7I Really Like Him (feat. Ernie Sabella, Robert Billig, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio)
8What Does He Want of Me (feat. Robert Billig, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio)
9Little Bird, Little Bird (feat. Robert Billig)
10Barber’s Song (feat. Robert Billig, Jamie Torcellini)
11Golden Helmet of Mambrino (feat. Ernie Sabella, Brian Stokes Mitchell, Robert Billig)
12To Each His Dulcinea (To Every Man His Dream) (feat. Stephen Bogardus, Mark Jacoby, Robert Billig)
13The Impossible Dream (The Quest) (feat. Brian Stokes Mitchell, Robert Billig)
14Knight of the Woeful Countenance (feat. Ernie Sabella, Robert Billig, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio)
15Aldonza (feat. Brian Stokes Mitchell, Robert Billig, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio)
16The Knight of the Mirrors (feat. Brian Stokes Mitchell, Stephen Bogardus, Robert Billig)
17I’m Only Thinking of Him (reprise) (feat. Robert Billig)
18A Little Gossip (feat. Ernie Sabella, Robert Billig)
19Final Sequence: The Death of Alonso Quijana (feat. Ernie Sabella, Brian Stokes Mitchell, Robert Billig, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio)
20Finale (feat. Robert Billig, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio)
