1What's Inside (feat. [theatre], Jessie Mueller)
2Opening Up (feat. [theatre], Jessie Mueller, Keala Settle, Kimiko Glenn, Eric Anderson)
3The Negative (feat. Jessie Mueller, Keala Settle, Kimiko Glenn)
4What Baking Can Do (feat. [theatre], Jessie Mueller)
5Club Knocked Up (feat. Aisha Jackson, Stephanie Torns, Molly Hager, Charity Angél Dawson)
6Pomatter Pie (feat. The Waitress Band)
7When He Sees Me (feat. [theatre], Jessie Mueller, Keala Settle, Kimiko Glenn)
8It Only Takes a Taste (feat. Jessie Mueller, Drew Gehling)
9You Will Still Be Mine (feat. Jessie Mueller, Nick Cordero)
10A Soft Place to Land (feat. Jessie Mueller, Keala Settle, Kimiko Glenn)
11Never Ever Getting Rid of Me (feat. [theatre], Kimiko Glenn, Christopher Fitzgerald)
12Bad Idea (feat. [theatre], Jessie Mueller, Drew Gehling)
13I Didn't Plan It (feat. Keala Settle)
14Bad Idea (reprise) (feat. [theatre], Jessie Mueller, Keala Settle, Kimiko Glenn, Eric Anderson, Drew Gehling, Christopher Fitzgerald)
15You Matter to Me (feat. Jessie Mueller, Drew Gehling)
16I Love You Like a Table (feat. [theatre], Kimiko Glenn, Christopher Fitzgerald)
17Take It From an Old Man (feat. [theatre], Dakin Matthews)
18Dear Baby (feat. Jessie Mueller)
19She Used to Be Mine (feat. Jessie Mueller)
20Contraction Ballet (feat. [theatre], Jessie Mueller)
21Everything Changes (feat. [theatre], Jessie Mueller, Keala Settle, Kimiko Glenn)
22Opening Up (Finale) (feat. [theatre])
